That said, I think that the Evers study raises a lot of questions that require further research.
- is midwifery care, with referral to obstetric care if complications arise, optimal care for low risk women?
- are there specific aspects the midwifery system in the Netherlands that are suboptimal (such as, protocols for intervals to check the fetal heart rate, as mentioned in the paper, or as one response to the study pointed out, the use of midwives assistants to watch over women until close to time of birth)?
- how might midwifery care be improved to result in better outcomes?
- how might collaboration between midwives and physicians be improved to result in better outcomes?
The answer to safety in maternity care is not to convince one side that the other is "right." The answer is respectful collaboration. This is not the first time I have talked about this. In October 2010, I committed to make my blog a doctor-friendly zone, and I hope that I have held true to that promise. I believe now, as I did then, that peaceful dialogue between doulas/activists/midwives and obstetricians and other hospital providers is essential for improving our maternity care system to protect the lives and and best meet the needs of mothers and babies. I believe that hospital and out-of-hospital providers could learn a lot from each other, which I think could help improve the safety of the practice of homebirth and care in transfers, as well as improve the environment and the options available to women in hospital birth. I have started to see dialogue opening up a little more in the past months, as more physicians are creating online presences and the internet is becoming a larger platform for conversation. I'm curious also, to see where the upcoming Home Birth Summit will lead.
I think your point that the way to making sure maternity care safe is not to prove oneself as right but collaboration is SO important.ReplyDelete
Debate only retrenches each side in their own bias and beliefs, collaboration on the other side encourages learning, compromise and change.